The Religion Forum - messages #161986 .1

The Religion Forum

Messages

Prospero Blocks

Hot Home Searches

Breakfast Recipes

Family Vacation Spots

Rachael Ray

Wine Guide

Babysitters

Chat Center

All Religion Topcs
Topic: Any topic, any religion.

Board Folders

	Christianity 107105 msgs in 1360 dscns Latest: 3:10 AM
	Judaism 25694 msgs in 952 dscns Latest: Nov-20
	Eastern Thought 5180 msgs in 111 dscns Latest: Nov-20
	Islam 16805 msgs in 467 dscns Latest: 12:14 AM
	Interfaith Issues 55000 msgs in 779 dscns Latest: 5:30 AM
	The Public Square 132590 msgs in 1922 dscns Latest: 6:41 AM
	Global Thought 19017 msgs in 355 dscns Latest: Oct-30
	Faith and Poli... 8286 msgs in 233 dscns Latest: Nov-20
	Freethinkers 11562 msgs in 211 dscns Latest: Nov-20
	Authors Online 1431 msgs in 69 dscns Latest: Oct-28
	Moral Choices 3411 msgs in 114 dscns Latest: Nov-20
	Latter-Day Saints 21581 msgs in 1365 dscns Latest: Nov-18
	Science & Reli... 18181 msgs in 349 dscns Latest: 6:17 AM
	Social Hall 103004 msgs in 2200 dscns Latest: Nov-20

Message Area

To list

New

...

Interfaith Issues

The Bible has Everything

Print Discussion

#1 of 191 Posted 1/28/07 10:25 AM

From Gary Z Posts 10990 Last Nov-20
To TONY [Msg # 161986.1 ]

Tony:

»»Chaya: Thus you didn't mean that everything could be found in the Bible. I have no problem with this variance.

»»You: I wouldn't put it that way. I believe everything can be found in the Bible, but it requires knowledge and faith, not knowledge alone.

Everything can be found in the Bible, huh? My coffee maker quit working. Where in the Bible can I find how to fix it?

Options

#2 of 191 Posted 1/28/07 8:38 PM

From TONY Posts 1371 Last 4/19/09
To Gary Z [Msg # 161986.2 161986.1 ]

Everything can be found in the Bible, huh? My coffee maker quit working. Where in the Bible can I find how to fix it?

You're a smart guy Gary, I'm sure you know what I meant by that statement.

WARNING: Comments made by Tony are opinions and should not be viewed as fact.

Subsequently, the preceeding statement should not be viewed as fact.

Options

#3 of 191 Posted 1/28/07 10:58 PM

From Gary Z Posts 10990 Last Nov-20
To TONY [Msg # 161986.3 161986.2 ]

Tony:

»»Me: Everything can be found in the Bible, huh? My coffee maker quit working. Where in the Bible can I find how to fix it?

»»You: You're a smart guy Gary, I'm sure you know what I meant by that statement.

I had a writing professor once that advised the class to "think through what you're writing." It was good advice. «g»

Options

#4 of 191 Posted 1/28/07 11:25 PM

From Mel [Staff] Posts 18093 Last Nov-20
To TONY [Msg # 161986.4 161986.2 ]

I'm sure you know what I meant by that statement.

Yet I have seen many Christians post the words, “Everything can be found in the Bible.”

Just to clarify it for me, could you explain just what a Christian means when they make this statement?

Options

#5 of 191 Posted 1/28/07 11:20 PM

From TONY Posts 1371 Last 4/19/09
To Gary Z [Msg # 161986.5 161986.3 ]

I had a writing professor once that advised the class to "think through what you're writing." It was good advice.

If I was writing a thesis or report, that would be great advice. In the case at hand, I believe the one I was writing to is an intelligent individual who wouldn't have a problem understanding what I meant, apparently, she understood it well enough. You are the only one who questioned it. Common sense says you can't look in the Bible to find the correct timing of a 302 ci engine, or troubleshooting tips for a coffee pot, so common sense would also tell you that is not what was meant by the statement. To answer your first question, it probably blew a fuse, which is easily replaceable, and if it's not the fuse, you'd be better off to buy another coffee maker. Or perhaps, you're drinking too much coffee.

WARNING: Comments made by Tony are opinions and should not be viewed as fact.

Subsequently, the preceeding statement should not be viewed as fact.

Options

#6 of 191 Posted 1/28/07 11:32 PM

From TONY Posts 1371 Last 4/19/09
To Mel [Staff] [Msg # 161986.6 161986.4 ]

Just to clarify it for me, could you explain just what a Christian means when they make this statement?

Everything we need to know pertaining to God.

WARNING: Comments made by Tony are opinions and should not be viewed as fact.

Subsequently, the preceeding statement should not be viewed as fact.

Options

#7 of 191 Posted 1/29/07 12:08 AM

From Mel [Staff] Posts 18093 Last Nov-20
To TONY [Msg # 161986.7 161986.6 ]

Everything we need to know pertaining to God.

How does this explanation not contradict with the words of James?

James 1: 5 If any of you lack wisdom, let him ask of God, that giveth to all men liberally, and upbraideth not; and it shall be given him.

Options

#8 of 191 Posted 1/29/07 12:41 AM

From TONY Posts 1371 Last 4/19/09
To Mel [Staff] [Msg # 161986.8 161986.7 ]

How does this explanation not contradict with the words of James?

James 1: 5 If any of you lack wisdom, let him ask of God, that giveth to all men liberally, and upbraideth not; and it shall be given him.

If you read my original comment, you would see that I said knowledge of the Bible leaves unanswered questions, faith leads us to the answers to those questions. Basically what I'm saying is that all the knowledge we need of the Bible, is in the Bible, without faith, one can go no further. As far as the scripture from James, without faith, one would not ask God for anything, so the statements aren't contradictory. Furthermore, wisdom and knowledge are two different things. One can have knowledge, and be dumber than a bag of hammers. Wisdom is knowing what to do with the knowledge one has.

WARNING: Comments made by Tony are opinions and should not be viewed as fact.

Subsequently, the preceeding statement should not be viewed as fact.

Options

#9 of 191 Posted 1/29/07 12:50 AM

From Mel [Staff] Posts 18093 Last Nov-20
To TONY [Msg # 161986.9 161986.8 ]

Basically what I'm saying is that all the knowledge we need of the Bible, is in the Bible,

And where does one find all the knowledge they need about God?

Options

#10 of 191 Posted 1/29/07 1:03 AM

From TONY Posts 1371 Last 4/19/09
To Mel [Staff] [Msg # 161986.10 161986.9 ]

And where does one find all the knowledge they need about God?

In the Bible.

WARNING: Comments made by Tony are opinions and should not be viewed as fact.

Subsequently, the preceeding statement should not be viewed as fact.

Options

#11 of 191 Posted 1/29/07 1:09 AM

From Mel [Staff] Posts 18093 Last Nov-20
To TONY [Msg # 161986.11 161986.10 ]

Tony: Basically what I'm saying is that all the knowledge we need of the Bible, is in the Bible,

Mel: And where does one find all the knowledge they need about God?

Tony: In the Bible.

And we complete the circle. I have been on this ride before, This is where I usually get off the ride and what other’s have to offer.

Options

Messages 161986.12 through 161986.13 were moved to 161996.1

#14 of 191 Posted 1/29/07 1:22 AM

From TONY Posts 1371 Last 4/19/09
To Mel [Staff] [Msg # 161986.14 161986.11 ]

And we complete the circle. I have been on this ride before, This is where I usually get off the ride and what other’s have to offer.

You asked a question, I answered it, what more do you want? If you wish to discuss something in more detail then spit it out, otherwise, I don't know what you're getting at.

WARNING: Comments made by Tony are opinions and should not be viewed as fact.

Subsequently, the preceeding statement should not be viewed as fact.

Options

Message 161986.15 was moved to 161996.3

#16 of 191 Posted 1/29/07 1:53 AM

From Mel [Staff] Posts 18093 Last Nov-20
To TONY [Msg # 161986.16 161986.14 ]

You asked a question, I answered it, what more do you want?

Not a thing, as I said, this is where I get off the merry-go-round.

Options

#17 of 191 Posted 1/29/07 2:12 AM

From TONY Posts 1371 Last 4/19/09
To Mel [Staff] [Msg # 161986.17 161986.16 ]

Not a thing, as I said, this is where I get off the merry-go-round.

Then why ask the question at all?

WARNING: Comments made by Tony are opinions and should not be viewed as fact.

Subsequently, the preceeding statement should not be viewed as fact.

Options

#18 of 191 Posted 1/29/07 2:18 AM

From Mel [Staff] Posts 18093 Last Nov-20
To TONY [Msg # 161986.18 161986.17 ]

Then why ask the question at all?

Let us see. I asked a question. You answered. Then I said I was no longer going to participate in the discussion because I have been on this ride before.

So, I would say I asked the question in hopes that I might receive an answer that did not depend on circular reasoning to justify.

I told you twice I getting off the ride. I did try to walk away from the conversation, did I not?

Options

#19 of 191 Posted 1/29/07 2:27 AM

From TONY Posts 1371 Last 4/19/09
To Mel [Staff] [Msg # 161986.19 161986.18 ]

So, I would say I asked the question in hopes that I might receive an answer that did not depend on circular reasoning to justify.

I don't think it depends on circular reasoning, I think it depends on faith, which I had already stated when you asked the question. Reasoning will only bring more confusion when it comes to the Bible. Some things have to be accepted on faith, or not accepted on lack of faith, but faith is the key.

I told you twice I getting off the ride. I did try to walk away from the conversation, did I not?

I knew some guys in school that would do that. They would pick a fight between two groups of people, and then sit back and watch them beat each other senseless.

WARNING: Comments made by Tony are opinions and should not be viewed as fact.

Subsequently, the preceeding statement should not be viewed as fact.

Options