Christian Fellowship Forum

     Go!
Prospero Blocks


 

Chat Center

Christians in 2006
Topic: Solutions for the new Century

Board Folders

The Fellowship Hall: 38881 msgs in 1665 dscns, Latest: 5:33 PMThe Fellowship...
38881 msgs in 1665 dscns
Latest: 5:33 PM
Christian Morals: 11710 msgs in 317 dscns, Latest: Feb-8 Christian Morals
11710 msgs in 317 dscns
Latest: Feb-8
Family Life: 3361 msgs in 178 dscns, Latest: Jan-5 Family Life
3361 msgs in 178 dscns
Latest: Jan-5
Prayer: 5919 msgs in 410 dscns, Latest: 4:04 PMPrayer
5919 msgs in 410 dscns
Latest: 4:04 PM
Bible Study & Discipleship: 36465 msgs in 675 dscns, Latest: 3:27 PMBible Study ...
36465 msgs in 675 dscns
Latest: 3:27 PM
Worship & the Arts: 1961 msgs in 144 dscns, Latest: Jan-29 Worship & the ...
1961 msgs in 144 dscns
Latest: Jan-29
Reading & Listening Room: 1768 msgs in 154 dscns, Latest: Feb-1 Reading & List...
1768 msgs in 154 dscns
Latest: Feb-1
Health & Wellness: 1388 msgs in 111 dscns, Latest: Feb-4 Health & Wellness
1388 msgs in 111 dscns
Latest: Feb-4
Mission & Ministry: 1376 msgs in 108 dscns, Latest: Dec-21 Mission & Mini...
1376 msgs in 108 dscns
Latest: Dec-21
Church/Parish Resources: 238 msgs in 21 dscns, Latest: Nov-23 Church/Parish ...
238 msgs in 21 dscns
Latest: Nov-23
The Last Days: 5772 msgs in 185 dscns, Latest: Feb-2 The Last Days
5772 msgs in 185 dscns
Latest: Feb-2
Christian Writers/Bloggers: 1533 msgs in 136 dscns, Latest: Dec-3 Christian Writ...
1533 msgs in 136 dscns
Latest: Dec-3
Contentious Brethren: 42489 msgs in 561 dscns, Latest: 12:02 PMContentious Br...
42489 msgs in 561 dscns
Latest: 12:02 PM
Public Affairs: 6408 msgs in 290 dscns, Latest: Feb-4 Public Affairs
6408 msgs in 290 dscns
Latest: Feb-4
Message Area
Contentious Brethren

Did God make you a soul?

 Subscribe SubscribeGet a printer-friendly version of this discussion Print Discussion 

#21 of 338

     Posted 10/2/07 7:56 AM   
Harold
 
From  Harold  Posts 10921  Last 3:33 PM
To  ozspen      [Msg # 117459.21 Message 117459.21 replying to 117459.17 117459.17 ]    

>>Isn't it amazing what you will do to twist the Scripture to arrive at your own SDA emphasis.  Take a read of these translations.:<<

How is that twisted?  Doesn't it read straight? Doesn't it make sense in the face of the entire Bible that states, clearly, that you don't have a soul, you ARE A SOUL.

I can't help it if you have thrown away the clear Word of God for something else that claims that you have an immortal soul. That isn't Biblical and you know it. Or at least you should if you read your Bible at all.  I don't know how many times I have ask to be shown the words "Immortal soul" in this forum.  Never got an answer.. Know why?  There isn't any such words. Never have been, never will be. 

 God clearly warned against believing in sprirts of dead people. Against witches and such.  Didn't you ever wonder why? That is one of Satan's best weapons. He is setting the world up to believe Jesus has come when it really is him impersonating Him.

The dead are dead. "The soul that sinneth shall die."  Then, look at John 3:16.  What in the world could be clearer?  Two classes. One with immortality and one without. Romans 6:23 says exactly the same thing. Then Rev.22:14 clearly states that only the saved have access to the tree of life. That sort of leaves sinners without it,doesn't it?  How do you have an immortal anything if you can't get to the tree of life?  think about it.

Harold.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply
Message 117459.22 was deleted

#23 of 338

     Posted 10/2/07 4:59 PM   
ozspen
 
From  ozspen  Posts 5339  Last Feb-8
To  Harold      [Msg # 117459.23 Message 117459.23 replying to 117459.21 117459.21 ]    
Harold,

Look at your tactics!  I provide you with 3 translations, including your beloved KJV, that demonstrate that a man (person -- male or female) has a soul and can lose it (Matt. 16:26) and I get this kind of avoidance by you.

Then you have the audacity of stating: <<I can't help it if you have thrown away the clear Word of God for something else that claims that you have an immortal soul.>>

I gave you the CLEAR word of God of Matt. 16:26 and you rejected it.  But you have the audacity to lie to me about what I did.  I gave the CLEAR word of God that man (a human being) has a soul that can be forfeited/lost.  That's Bible.  Get it, Harold! 

I was not dealing with the topic of an immortal soul.   I gave you the clear word of God from your beloved KJV of Matt. 16:26.

You don't have a clue about the Bible's meaning of death.  Jesus stated to Martha and to us: "I am the resurrection and the life.  Whoever believes in me, though he die, yet shall he live"  AND DO YOU GET THIS, HAROLD? "Everyone who lives and believe in me SHALL NEVER DIE.  DO YOU BELIEVE THIS?" (John 11:25-26).  You obviously don't believe this, Harold.

You can quote "the soul that sinneth shall die" (Ezek. 18:4, 20) until you are blue in the face, but when you don't understand the meaning of death (as you have demonstrated here), you are always going to come up with false doctrine on this topic.  Death is separation from God for the unbeliever and not extinction.

Sincerely,
Spencer
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply
Message 117459.24 was deleted

#25 of 338

     Posted 10/3/07 10:08 AM   
Harold
 
From  Harold  Posts 10921  Last 3:33 PM
To  ozspen      [Msg # 117459.25 Message 117459.25 replying to 117459.23 117459.23 ]    

<<You can quote "the soul that sinneth shall die" (Ezek. 18:4, 20) until you are blue in the face, <<

And you still wouldn't believe it..  I can see why.  You have been so conditioned by your church that unless it says something is so, it isn't in your eyes.  Don't forget, that isn't the only scripture I have sent. John 3:16, Romans 6:23 all say the same thing. Only the saved have immortality.  And, you have yet to show me any 'immortal soul' scriptures.

Why do you want to keep Satan's lie going?  You don't have a soul. You ARE a soul. It is YOU.

Wait till I get home and I can find lots more on this.
Leaving at noon today. Be home tonight. Probably won't get on here until tomorrow, though.

Harold.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#26 of 338

     Posted 10/3/07 4:39 PM   
ozspen
 
From  ozspen  Posts 5339  Last Feb-8
To  Harold      [Msg # 117459.26 Message 117459.26 replying to 117459.25 117459.25 ]    
Harold,

>>You have been so conditioned by your church that unless it says something is so, it isn't in your eyes.<<

You are the pot calling the kettle black!

Sincerely,
Spencer
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#27 of 338

     Posted 10/4/07 12:40 AM   
FATHERJIMPARKER
 
From  FATHERJIMPARKER  Posts 5694  Last 11:49 AM
To  ozspen      [Msg # 117459.27 Message 117459.27 replying to 117459.26 117459.26 ]    

<<You are the pot calling the kettle black!>>

Not quite. You're not a kettle. <s>

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#28 of 338

     Posted 10/4/07 2:43 AM   
ozspen
 
From  ozspen  Posts 5339  Last Feb-8
To  FATHERJIMPARKER      [Msg # 117459.28 Message 117459.28 replying to 117459.27 117459.27 ]    
Jim,
>>Not quite. You're not a kettle. <s><< 
Thanks for that.  However, that's how the cliche plays out Down Under.

From the encounter on this topic, I'm moving towards the view that it is a waste of time interacting with Harold on his cult's theology that contradicts orthodox theology.  I have continued because there are others who read the thread.

However, I don't have the time to go over and over the same biblical material.  I can offer a biblical refutation to Harold on one thread and he raises the very same question on another threat to me, as he did recently with: "Where is King David?"

What's your experience on this forum and elsewhere with cultists?  If it were not for evangelicals who persisted with my friends, Mark & Rita, who are former SDAs (25 years in the cult), they would not have considered the biblical evidence that refutes the SDA position.  Today they are serving God enthusiastically in an evangelical church.

However, at this point, I observe that Harold is so resistant to a careful examination of what the Bible states, that interacting with him seems to be a waste of space.  He works with inferior exegetical tools (eg Strong's concordance) and doesn't seem to have a handle on how to do accurate exegesis.

I'd be interested in your views.

Sincerely,
Spencer
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#29 of 338

     Posted 10/4/07 3:32 AM   
FATHERJIMPARKER
 
From  FATHERJIMPARKER  Posts 5694  Last 11:49 AM
To  ozspen      [Msg # 117459.29 Message 117459.29 replying to 117459.28 117459.28 ]    

I have come to view his and other’s inability to process simple data that contradicts SDA teaching as a demonically induced dementia, an insanity.

Irrational responses that would normally be considered within the realm of insanity are:
1. The belief that one belongs to an exclusive group that alone among all Christian denominations truly understands scripture.
2. The belief that the Pope and the RCC has controlled the minds of every believer since the beginning of the church and only the SDA has escaped the RCC’s evil grip.
3. The inability to process simple statements if they contradict what his cult has taught him. His response that “…Jesus declared all foods clean” does not mean Jesus actually declared all foods clean but that it was simply a “spurious” comment at the end of a discussion about washing hands or, rather than allow the words to mean what they obviously mean, to try to redefine the word “food” are examples of the extent that he will go to in order to avoid dealing with the reality of the simple meaning of the words.
4. A neglect to respond to a comment that he cannot refute as if the comment had never been made. This allows him to pretend that no refutation of his programming exists. He simply ignores it out of existence so he doesn’t have to deal with it.

That reminds me of a situation we had about 15 years ago in California. A group of Cambodian women, refugees from Pol Pot’s murderous insanity, were all blind but there was no evidence of any cause of the blindness. What was eventually determined was that the women had seen so much evil that they simply stopped seeing in order to protect their sanity. As a survival device, their minds simply refused to see any more. Cult members have a similar situation. They have become so dependant upon the approval of their cult that any challenge to their continuing membership is perceived as a survival threat and their minds have created methods to prevent them from recognizing anything that might separate them from the cult which has become their only source of meaningful existence. Any form of separation from the cult, or even to consider an idea that is contradictory to cultic teaching is subconsciously interpreted as life threatening.

That’s what I see in Harold and every other SDA member who has ventured into this forum to set us free from the control of Darth Poper and the evil RCC Empire.

I think there is no escape for any of them without the consistent, fervent prayers of believers binding of the demons that cause the cult mentality. Those demons include dementia, confusion, blindness, religious pride, arrogance, false religion, false prophesy, self-righteousness and probably at least a dozen others. They operate in clusters. (That should cause some interesting responses. Perhaps a howl or two)

jim


Edited 10/4/07   by  FATHERJIMPARKER
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#30 of 338

     Posted 10/4/07 4:00 AM   
ozspen
 
From  ozspen  Posts 5339  Last Feb-8
To  FATHERJIMPARKER      [Msg # 117459.30 Message 117459.30 replying to 117459.29 117459.29 ]    
Jim,

That was such an excellent post of the dynamics of what you understand is involved with cultic indoctrination.  It seems to line up with the blindness I have experienced from Harold. 

A typical example was when we were discussing human beings having a soul (with which he disagrees) and he quoted another translation than his favourite KJV which reads in Matt. 16:26: "For what is a man profited, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul? or what shall a man give in exchange for his soul?"  I drew this to his attention, but there has been no response from him on that element.  It's amazing what he will do to avoid the obvious? 

Sincerely,
Spencer
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#31 of 338

     Posted 10/4/07 8:57 AM   
Harold
 
From  Harold  Posts 10921  Last 3:33 PM
To  ozspen      [Msg # 117459.31 Message 117459.31 replying to 117459.26 117459.26 ]    

>>You are the pot calling the kettle black!>>

Oh, sure.  I quote scripture and you quote traditions. That makes me wrong.  You are only upset because you have nothing  to back up what you claim to be the truth. Try finding it in the Bible.  I have ask till I am blue in the face for someone to show me the words "Immortal soul."  Everybody just keeps beating around the bush with their traditions and nothing from the Bible.

When you wake up and discover that your traditions are NOT from the Word of God, let me know.

Harold.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#32 of 338

     Posted 10/4/07 9:13 AM   
tomyeahbut
 
From  tomyeahbut  Posts 3535  Last Oct-25
To  FATHERJIMPARKER      [Msg # 117459.32 Message 117459.32 replying to 117459.29 117459.29 ]    

<That’s what I see in Harold and every other SDA member who has ventured into this forum to set us free from the control of Darth Poper and the evil RCC Empire.>

You don't have to fear the Gollum. (s) You should stay in the third person to keep strong in debate. Your four bullet points were more effective and much better than getting all flustered emotionally. Don't sink to their level.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#33 of 338

     Posted 10/4/07 9:20 AM   
Harold
 
From  Harold  Posts 10921  Last 3:33 PM
To  tomyeahbut      [Msg # 117459.33 Message 117459.33 replying to 117459.32 117459.32 ]    

>> Don't sink to their level.>>

Right.  Don't resort to scripture.

Harold.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#34 of 338

     Posted 10/4/07 9:39 AM   
tomyeahbut
 
From  tomyeahbut  Posts 3535  Last Oct-25
To  Harold      [Msg # 117459.34 Message 117459.34 replying to 117459.33 117459.33 ]    

<Don't resort to scripture.>

Not exactly, don't use similar names and terms with different definitions, such as you do with wine.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#35 of 338

     Posted 10/4/07 3:13 PM   
ozspen
 
From  ozspen  Posts 5339  Last Feb-8
To  Harold      [Msg # 117459.35 Message 117459.35 replying to 117459.31 117459.31 ]    
Harold,
>> I have ask till I am blue in the face for someone to show me the words "Immortal soul." <<
Please show me the word, "Trinity," in the Bible.

Sincerely,
Spencer
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#36 of 338

     Posted 10/4/07 5:55 PM   
Harold
 
From  Harold  Posts 10921  Last 3:33 PM
To  ozspen      [Msg # 117459.36 Message 117459.36 replying to 117459.35 117459.35 ]    

>>Please show me the word, "Trinity," in the Bible.>>

1 John 5:7  "For there are three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost: and these three are one."

Matthew 28:19 "Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost: "

I am just going to assume that you can count.  That is what 'trinity' means. Three.

Harold.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#37 of 338

     Posted 10/4/07 11:39 PM   
ozspen
 
From  ozspen  Posts 5339  Last Feb-8
To  Harold      [Msg # 117459.37 Message 117459.37 replying to 117459.36 117459.36 ]    
Harold,
>>I am just going to assume that you can count.  That is what 'trinity' means. Three.<<
Your point is valid and its the very point I am making.  Not once is the word "trinity" mentioned in the Bible but the doctrine is clearly taught.  Just as "immortal soul" does not have to be mentioned for the doctrine to be clearly taught.

Sincerely,
Spencer
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#38 of 338

     Posted 10/5/07 3:21 AM   
FATHERJIMPARKER
 
From  FATHERJIMPARKER  Posts 5694  Last 11:49 AM
To  ozspen      [Msg # 117459.38 Message 117459.38 replying to 117459.30 117459.30 ]    

<< It's amazing what he will do to avoid the obvious?>>

"The obvious" has the potential to be psychologically painful to a cult member who perceives a threat to his cult's worldview in what is obvious to others.

A madman will not accept that fact that he's not Napoleon. If you destroy his identity with reality then he's left with the question, "Who am I?" and no answer. It is also a threat to his source of affirmation. If he denies the false teachings of his cult then, logically, he should remove himself from their circle of influence and the affirmation they provide. Unfortunately, to do so would leave the ex-cult member without a circle of friends because cults tend to isolate their members from outsiders by implanting the idea that all outsiders are evil or dangerous or heretics. (Note Harold's phobia toward the RCC and the Pope.)

A threat to any part of a cult’s dogma is a threat to the cult member’s personal identity. Members are indoctrinated with the idea that the world outside the cult is chaotic and dangerous while the womb of the cult is safe and nurturing. To leave the cult is to experience a kind of death. Indeed that is what scripture states, “Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation; the old has gone, the new has come!” (2COR5:17) and “For you died, and your life is now hidden with Christ in God.” (COL 3:3)

jim

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#39 of 338

     Posted 10/5/07 3:22 AM   
FATHERJIMPARKER
 
From  FATHERJIMPARKER  Posts 5694  Last 11:49 AM
To  tomyeahbut      [Msg # 117459.39 Message 117459.39 replying to 117459.32 117459.32 ]    

Thank you for that insightful comment. (seriously!)

jim

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#40 of 338

     Posted 10/5/07 3:58 AM   
ozspen
 
From  ozspen  Posts 5339  Last Feb-8
To  FATHERJIMPARKER      [Msg # 117459.40 Message 117459.40 replying to 117459.38 117459.38 ]    
Jim,

Once again, an excellent response.  Your insight into cults and their thinking has been enlightening to me.  Thanks so much for your input.

Spencer
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply
 Subscribe SubscribeGet a printer-friendly version of this discussion Print Discussion 
Contentious Brethren

Did God make you a soul?

  
 
     

Welcome, Guest

  • Post a message
  • New messages to you
  • Log in

Start Search
Advanced Search

Prospero Blocks
 
 
 
Special Offers
 
 
 

Cool Clicks!

 
 
 

Finding People

 
 
 
© 2009 CompuServe Interactive Services, Inc. All rights reserved.

Legal Notices | Privacy Policy