Political Debate

     Go!
Prospero Blocks


 

Chat Center

We the People
Topic: Anything you want to talk about.

Board Folders

Congress: 8824 msgs in 3471 dscns, Latest: Nov-21 Congress
8824 msgs in 3471 dscns
Latest: Nov-21
Republicans: 68630 msgs in 1802 dscns, Latest: 2:54 AMRepublicans
68630 msgs in 1802 dscns
Latest: 2:54 AM
Democrats: 46070 msgs in 1006 dscns, Latest: Nov-20 Democrats
46070 msgs in 1006 dscns
Latest: Nov-20
American Issues: 115144 msgs in 2443 dscns, Latest: 8:26 AMAmerican Issues
115144 msgs in 2443 dscns
Latest: 8:26 AM
Gun Rights: 53490 msgs in 839 dscns, Latest: Nov-21 Gun Rights
53490 msgs in 839 dscns
Latest: Nov-21
The Obama Administration: 113646 msgs in 2200 dscns, Latest: 1:05 AMThe Obama Admi...
113646 msgs in 2200 dscns
Latest: 1:05 AM
International Affairs: 144109 msgs in 2659 dscns, Latest: Nov-20 International ...
144109 msgs in 2659 dscns
Latest: Nov-20
Marginal Issues: 138862 msgs in 8585 dscns, Latest: 7:04 AMMarginal Issues
138862 msgs in 8585 dscns
Latest: 7:04 AM
Religion & Science: 123111 msgs in 1265 dscns, Latest: 1:27 AMReligion ...
123111 msgs in 1265 dscns
Latest: 1:27 AM
The Economy: 31286 msgs in 631 dscns, Latest: 4:27 AMThe Economy
31286 msgs in 631 dscns
Latest: 4:27 AM
The Media: 55512 msgs in 1263 dscns, Latest: 2:49 AMThe Media
55512 msgs in 1263 dscns
Latest: 2:49 AM
The Courts: 27086 msgs in 346 dscns, Latest: Nov-21 The Courts
27086 msgs in 346 dscns
Latest: Nov-21
Campaign 2010: 66204 msgs in 1880 dscns, Latest: Nov-21 Campaign 2010
66204 msgs in 1880 dscns
Latest: Nov-21
Bill of Rights: 30121 msgs in 356 dscns, Latest: Sep-27 Bill of Rights
30121 msgs in 356 dscns
Latest: Sep-27
Message Area
Republicans

Did She Say Her "retarded baby"?

 Subscribe SubscribeGet a printer-friendly version of this discussion Print Discussion 

#1 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 12:05 PM   
Jon Fredersen
 
From  Jon Fredersen  Posts 4215  Last Nov-21
To  All      [Msg # 213435.1 ]    

Well, Levi Johnston is making "Joe the Plumber" look like "Joe the Flash in the Pan" as he tries to turn having knocked up Bristol Palin into a career.

He's still here.  He's still got a publicist, I'm guessing, who is finding ways to rake in the "do-re-me."

As nauseating as it is to see this guy in the media, his latest ploy in capitalizing on Sarah Palin's fame reveals some very disturbing claims about her.

Among other things, Johnston said Palin joked about her son Trig's Down Syndrome, calling him her "retarded baby."

"I was just in shock the first time I heard it," he said, when host Maggie Rodriguez expressed disbelief. He also said Bristol took care of the baby much more than her mother: "Sarah was never home."

Read more at: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/10/27/levi-johnston-on-cbs-earl_n_335866.html

Well, you have to consider the source.  Disgruntled guy from his own dysfunctional family, using Palin's fame to make a career out of personal "fame."

Something of a sleazebag himself.

But still, is he telling the truth?

Sleazebags may tell the truth for their own gain; but, if it's the truth it should be considered when assessing Palin's own character, or lack thereof.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#2 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 1:06 PM   
EmptyNest
 
From  EmptyNest  Posts 1109  Last Nov-21
To  Jon Fredersen      [Msg # 213435.2 Message 213435.2 replying to 213435.1 213435.1 ]    

}}}}} But still, is he telling the truth? {{{{{

Why do you care?

I find it very strange that using the word *retarded* has somehow become unacceptable.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#3 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 1:18 PM   
Jon Fredersen
 
From  Jon Fredersen  Posts 4215  Last Nov-21
To  EmptyNest      [Msg # 213435.3 Message 213435.3 replying to 213435.2 213435.2 ]    

JF: }}}}} But still, is he telling the truth? {{{{{

E: Why do you care?  I find it very strange that using the word *retarded* has somehow become unacceptable.

The real question is why you don't care.

I don't know of a family with special needs children who don't find the term "retarded" degrading and hurtful, not to mention such folks themselves.

I care, since you ask, because they care.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#4 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 1:22 PM   
EmptyNest
 
From  EmptyNest  Posts 1109  Last Nov-21
To  Jon Fredersen      [Msg # 213435.4 Message 213435.4 replying to 213435.3 213435.3 ]    

}}}}}}} I don't know of a family with special needs children who don't find the term "retarded" degrading and hurtful, not to mention such folks themselves. {{{{{{{

[shrug]  I grew up with an uncle with down's syndrome who was only 4 years older than me, and it was never an issue in our family.

But we were just poor country folk.


Edited Oct-28   by  EmptyNest
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#5 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 1:32 PM   
nukem
 
From  nukem  Posts 11677  Last Nov-21
To  EmptyNest      [Msg # 213435.5 Message 213435.5 replying to 213435.2 213435.2 ]    

I find it very strange that using the word *retarded* has somehow become unacceptable.

I find  anything Levi Johnston says and caring about it is retarded.

gary

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#6 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 1:36 PM   
Sysop Jim Dellon
 
From  Sysop Jim Dellon  Posts 30265  Last Nov-21
To  Jon Fredersen      [Msg # 213435.6 Message 213435.6 replying to 213435.1 213435.1 ]    
Jon --

>>Sleazebags may tell the truth for their own gain; but, if it's the truth it should be considered when assessing Palin's own character, or lack thereof.<<

I wouldn't take anything that Levi Johnston has to say seriously.

Sarah Palin herself has given us plenty of reasons to think poorly of her, but the words of a disgruntled ex-future-son-in-law looking to cash in and extend his 15 minutes of fame aren't among them.

-- jim
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#7 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 1:36 PM   
Jon Fredersen
 
From  Jon Fredersen  Posts 4215  Last Nov-21
To  EmptyNest      [Msg # 213435.7 Message 213435.7 replying to 213435.4 213435.4 ]    

JF:}}}}}}} I don't know of a family with special needs children who don't find the term "retarded" degrading and hurtful, not to mention such folks themselves. {{{{{{{

E: [shrug]  I grew up with an uncle with down's syndrome who was only 4 years older than me, and it was never an issue in our family.  But we were just poor country folk.

You know, I don't much care whether you shrug it off or not.

I know lots of good people, with problems and without, who are seriously hurt by people for whom the word "retarded" was/is not an issue.  My wife works with those families every day.

Doesn't matter if you had a family member with Downs Syndrome or not.

That word is hurtful, often viciously applied, and folks who use it these days deserve to be answerable to those they hurt through the using it, in my view.

Anyone who wants to rail about "political correctness," I don't much care about either.

It's a question of basic human decency and personal empathy as far as I'm concerned.

And, while it's fair to examine politicians for those qualities, no matter what party, I'm not at all impressed by those who are cruel, and repeatedly so, in their attitude and language, and try to justify themselves by bologna about fighting "political correctness."

Yeah, I know you didn't mention "political correctness."  But, if you didn't someone else would.....


Edited Oct-28   by  Jon Fredersen

Edited Oct-28   by  Jon Fredersen
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#8 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 1:41 PM   
joanna123jn
 
From  joanna123jn  Posts 9029  Last 7:29 AM
To  nukem      [Msg # 213435.8 Message 213435.8 replying to 213435.5 213435.5 ]    

I find  anything Levi Johnston says and caring about it is retarded.

I do too.  Why doesn't he just go away?

 

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#9 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 1:49 PM   
Jon Fredersen
 
From  Jon Fredersen  Posts 4215  Last Nov-21
To  Sysop Jim Dellon      [Msg # 213435.9 Message 213435.9 replying to 213435.6 213435.6 ]    

JD: I wouldn't take anything that Levi Johnston has to say seriously.  Sarah Palin herself has given us plenty of reasons to think poorly of her, but the words of a disgruntled ex-future-son-in-law looking to cash in and extend his 15 minutes of fame aren't among them.

There's nothing you said that I really disagree with.

But, sometimes the sleazebags tell the truth because it's in their best interests.

Sometimes they aren't telling the truth.

If apparent character were a foolproof way to determine factual accuracy, life would be easier. 

But, pillars of the community are known to have lied through their teeth sometimes. 

So, it's not always that easy to accept or reject the factual accuracy of something based only on the character of the speaker.

Skepticism is warranted, a lot of it in fact.  I certainly wouldn't make any real decision about Palin based on anything this guy would say.

But, he's definitely in a position to be telling the truth.  So, an open mind is warranted as well.

And, the issue isn't a small one; because, if true, it's revealing of a streak of cruelty and lack of empathy that would impact fitness for political office.

Let her deny it, as I think she should, then see what happens.

If true, there's a good chance someone else will step forward to bolster his claims; because, it there is that character flaw in Palin it's doubtful Johnston was the only one to have seen it.

If no one can lend credence to him, then the probability that he's just fishing for glory and abusing the truth is all the greater.


 

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#10 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 1:57 PM   
EmptyNest
 
From  EmptyNest  Posts 1109  Last Nov-21
To  Jon Fredersen      [Msg # 213435.10 Message 213435.10 replying to 213435.9 213435.9 ]    

}}}}} And, the issue isn't a small one; because, if true, it's revealing of a streak of cruelty and lack of empathy that would impact fitness for political office. {{{{{

It's her baby.  I think she can use any term she deems appropriate.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#11 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 2:05 PM   
nukem
 
From  nukem  Posts 11677  Last Nov-21
To  joanna123jn      [Msg # 213435.11 Message 213435.11 replying to 213435.8 213435.8 ]    

I find  anything Levi Johnston says and caring about it is retarded.

I do too.  Why doesn't he just go away?

If I were young, single and stupid....I'd ride that wave as long as I could. Believe me...the cameras follow him around.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/10/05/levi-johnstons-tv-commerc_n_309738.html

gary

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#12 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 2:06 PM   
Jon Fredersen
 
From  Jon Fredersen  Posts 4215  Last Nov-21
To  EmptyNest      [Msg # 213435.12 Message 213435.12 replying to 213435.10 213435.10 ]    

JF: }}}}} And, the issue isn't a small one; because, if true, it's revealing of a streak of cruelty and lack of empathy that would impact fitness for political office. {{{{{

E: It's her baby.  I think she can use any term she deems appropriate.

Anyone with a Downs Syndrome child is allowed to be verbally just about as cruel and hurtful as they want.  I've seen families where this kind of verbal cruelty is them on a good day. 

The threshhold to legally sanctioned abuse leaves a lot of room for hurting your child and insulting and hurting others.

It's a free country.  And, life isn't pretty all the time.

If this is true of her, and it's a big if at this moment, the rest of us are free to disparage her cruelty and lack of empathy.

Or, if it's not true, to call out this Johnston clown for the creep that he is, and a liar also if he's that.


Edited Oct-28   by  Jon Fredersen
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#13 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 2:25 PM   
Parema7
 
From  Parema7  Posts 10268  Last Nov-21
To  Jon Fredersen      [Msg # 213435.13 Message 213435.13 replying to 213435.12 213435.12 ]    

<<<Or, if it's not true, to call out this Johnston clown for the creep that he is, and a liar also if he's that.>>>

I didn't see the program where Levi Johnston was interviewed by Maggie Rodriguez and am sorry I missed it. But--Johnston has made these very same claims several times before. He spoke, in a past interview, of Palin arriving home one day while he and Bristol were taking care of both babies and he reported that Palin, instead of picking up her own child said, "I don't want the retarded baby, I want the other baby." She then disappeared into her bedroom as was her habit and left Bristol to continue taking care of both babies. Levi has said many times before that Bristol was the one taking care of Palin's baby along with her own the majority of the time and that Bristol was the one left with the responsibility of taking care of the household, the cooking and helping her little sister with homework.

No, it is not a flattering picture. Would I be surprised if there were lots of truth to it? Not at all. Perhaps eventually, other people will speak up to either deny or corroborate Johnston's claims.

To those who ask WHY we should be interested in such claims----this is a woman who plans to launch a new organization around the same time her book appears on the market and, according to those in the know, this new organization is expected to be seen as a forerunner to Palin's run for president in 2012. If that is the case and this woman has her sights set on a run for president, we ALL need to know as much as we can about her character.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#14 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 3:12 PM   
nukem
 
From  nukem  Posts 11677  Last Nov-21
To  Parema7      [Msg # 213435.14 Message 213435.14 replying to 213435.13 213435.13 ]    

 instead of picking up her own child said, "I don't want the retarded baby, I want the other baby." She then disappeared into her bedroom as was her habit and left Bristol to continue taking care of both babies.

Good grief. I can't believe people who believe this are allowed to vote.

gary

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#15 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 3:40 PM   
Jim
 
From  Jim  Posts 471  Last Nov-21
To  Sysop Jim Dellon      [Msg # 213435.15 Message 213435.15 replying to 213435.6 213435.6 ]    
<<I wouldn't take anything that Levi Johnston has to say seriously.>>

The same thing was said about the late Martha Mitchell who alleged officials in the Nixon White House were engaged in illegal activities.   At the time,  her claims were attributed to mental illness.   Ultimately,  however,  the relevant facts of Watergate vindicated her.

'Disgruntled' ?  Perhaps.  He could also be accurate too.
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#16 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 3:53 PM   
Jim Odom
 
From  Jim Odom  Posts 6707  Last Nov-20
To  Jon Fredersen      [Msg # 213435.16 Message 213435.16 replying to 213435.9 213435.9 ]    

<<But, sometimes the sleazebags tell the truth because it's in their best interests.>>

A dubious claim, at best.  

<<So, it's not always that easy to accept or reject the factual accuracy of something based only on the character of the speaker.>>

There's virtually no way to accept or reject the veracity of such a claim no matter who says it.

<<But, he's definitely in a position to be telling the truth. >>

Considering everything, he's in a far greater position to take a grain of truth and blow it way out of proportion for his own benefit.

<<Let her deny it, as I think she should, then see what happens.>>

She'd be a fool to do anything of the sort.

<<And, the issue isn't a small one; because, if true, it's revealing of a streak of cruelty and lack of empathy that would impact fitness for political office.>>

Not necessarily.  While "retarded" is generally considered an insensitive term, there is no way of knowing the context under which it was said.

<<If no one can lend credence to him, then the probability that he's just fishing for glory and abusing the truth is all the greater.>>

Face it, Jon:  you just don't like her.  On that, we agree.  But as Jim D. said, there's plenty of legitimate reasons to oppose her without wallowing in gossip and conjecture.

<<As nauseating as it is to see this guy in the media.......>>

Has it occurred to you that by starting this thread, you're contributing to your own nausea?


Edited Oct-28   by  Jim Odom
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#17 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 4:17 PM   
gordonhofer
 
From  gordonhofer  Posts 31261  Last Nov-21
To  joanna123jn      [Msg # 213435.17 Message 213435.17 replying to 213435.8 213435.8 ]    
I do too.  Why doesn't he just go away?

Because people like Frederson keep giving him time, with silly questions like, "Is he telling the truth?" How would anyone here know if he's telling the truth?
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#18 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 4:20 PM   
gordonhofer
 
From  gordonhofer  Posts 31261  Last Nov-21
To  Jim      [Msg # 213435.18 Message 213435.18 replying to 213435.15 213435.15 ]    
The same thing was said about the late Martha Mitchell who alleged officials in the Nixon White House were engaged in illegal activities.   At the time,  her claims were attributed to mental illness.   Ultimately,  however,  the relevant facts of Watergate vindicated her.

Ergo, all people who make outrageous claims must be believed. LOL !!!
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#19 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 4:22 PM   
Jim
 
From  Jim  Posts 471  Last Nov-21
To  gordonhofer      [Msg # 213435.19 Message 213435.19 replying to 213435.18 213435.18 ]    
<<Ergo, all people who make outrageous claims must be believed. >>

Really????   How adorable.
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#20 of 145

     Posted Oct-28 4:48 PM   
Jon Fredersen
 
From  Jon Fredersen  Posts 4215  Last Nov-21
To  nukem      [Msg # 213435.20 Message 213435.20 replying to 213435.14 213435.14 ]    

n: Good grief. I can't believe people who believe this are allowed to vote.

Not that you'd ever believe any evidence that proved it to be true, but you could always pledge to never vote again if it turns out to be true. :-)

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply
 Subscribe SubscribeGet a printer-friendly version of this discussion Print Discussion 
Republicans

Did She Say Her "retarded baby"?

  
 
     
 
 

Sponsored Links of the Day

 
• 

Are You Safe to Drive?


Find an approved, inexpensive breathalyzer testing device to learn about blood alcohol levels and to better know your limit. Get a Tester Today
http://search.compuserve.com
 
• 

Looking for Love?


Match.com...The best way to meet local singles. Start your search now!
http://www.match.com
 
• 

Get A Flat Screen


Are you still squinting with a dim, fuzzy computer monitor? Get a crisp new flat panel that saves space and energy. Upgrade your Computer!
http://search.compuserve.com
 

Welcome, Guest

  • Post a message
  • New messages to you
  • Log in

Start Search
Advanced Search

Prospero Blocks
 
 
 
Special Offers
 
 
 

Finding People

 
 
 

Cool Clicks!

 
 
 
© 2009 CompuServe Interactive Services, Inc. All rights reserved.

Legal Notices | Privacy Policy